This post may contain affiliate links. Please see my disclosure policy for details.
The Cozy-Comfort Crew: For When You Just Want to Chill
Contents
Pizza and Pajamas Night
This theme saved my sanity last year. I told everyone to show up in their best holiday pajamas, ordered a mountain of pizza, and set up a DIY pizza bar with ridiculous toppings. We watched cheesy Christmas rom-coms, and nobody had to worry about spilling marinara sauce on fancy clothes.
What you’ll need:
- Holiday themed pajama sets for yourself (bonus points if you provide extras for forgetful friends)
- Pizza (duh)
- Throw blankets scattered everywhere
- A good streaming queue
The beauty here is zero pressure. Everyone’s comfortable, the food is easy, and you’re not stuck in the kitchen while your friends have fun without you.
Comfy and Cozy Vibes
I’m talking maximum hygge energy here. Dim the overhead lights (they’re the enemy of ambiance anyway), light every candle you own, and create cozy nesting spots around your space. Set up a hot cocoa bar that would make Instagram jealous.
The setup:
- Scented candles in every corner
- Fuzzy socks as party favors
- Oversized sweaters required
- Acoustic Christmas music, not that aggressive Mariah belt
I keep a basket of extra fuzzy blankets by the door because someone always shows up underdressed for a cozy theme.
Favorite Things Party
Oprah made this famous, but I’ve adapted it for friends who actually have budgets. Everyone brings 3-5 of the same inexpensive item they genuinely love (under $10-15 each). You draw numbers and pick items one at a time, and everyone goes home with things people actually use. I’ve gotten amazing face masks, fancy hot sauce, and a wine stopper that changed my life through these exchanges. No more junk nobody wants sitting in closets until next year’s garage sale.
Pajamas and Prosecco
This is the sophisticated older sister of pizza and pajamas. Same comfort level, elevated execution. Silk pajamas, champagne cocktails, and maybe some fancy cheese instead of pizza rolls. I serve mimosas with a prosecco bar featuring different fruit purees and fresh herbs. People feel fancy while still being comfortable enough to sit cross-legged on the floor.
Sock Swap Spectacular
The most weirdly popular theme I’ve ever hosted. Everyone brings wrapped pairs of ridiculous, cozy, or funny socks. You do a typical gift exchange, but the stakes are delightfully low and everyone leaves with warm feet. I’ve witnessed near-fistfights over socks with tiny tacos on them. The competitive energy over $8 socks is absolutely unmatched.
The Glam Squad: For When You Want to Get Fancy
Sip, Snack, and Sleigh
This theme lets you show off if you’re into that. I set up a charcuterie spread that takes up my entire dining table, create a signature cocktail, and hang string lights absolutely everywhere. The vibe is “elegant but still fun” – like a dinner party that doesn’t have a stick up its ass.
My game plan:
- One killer charcuterie board (go bigger than you think)
- Two signature cocktails max (don’t overwhelm yourself)
- Simple games like holiday trivia or charades
- Twinkle lights creating that magical glow
Let’s Get LIT (Literally)
Every light source at this party glows, sparkles, or twinkles. I’m talking string lights, LED ice cubes in drinks, glow sticks, light-up jewelry – the whole shebang. My apartment looked like a nightclub collided with Santa’s workshop, and honestly, it was magical. Get LED light up glasses for guests as they arrive. The photos from this party are absolutely ridiculous and I treasure them.
Let’s Get Elfed Up
This is my favorite slightly inappropriate theme. Everyone wears elf hats, we serve candy cane cocktails, and I set up a photo booth with props. The pun does the heavy lifting here. Create a signature drink called the “Elfed Up Elixir” or “Bad Elf” and let the party name itself.
Making Spirits Bright
Here’s where it gets interactive. Everyone brings ingredients for their signature holiday cocktail and teaches the group how to make it. You end up with a cocktail crawl in one location. I provide the base spirits and mixers, guests bring their special ingredients and recipe cards. Fair warning: pace yourself or you’ll be making spirits a little too bright.
Let’s Jingle and Mingle
This works best for larger groups where people don’t all know each other. Set up different stations around your space – a hot cocoa bar, a candy cane mimosa station, a cookie decorating corner. People naturally migrate and mix as they explore. I use this theme when I’m combining friend groups. The stations give people an activity and conversation starter beyond “so… how do you know the host?”
